Monday, June 9, 2014

ONE DIRECTOR. 3 DIFFERENT SHOWS.

THOMAS OSTERMEIER. In the past two weeks, I’ve seen three of his productions. Tonight Jase & I rushed tickets for Die kleinen Fuchse ("The Little Foxes”) by Lillian Hellman. After seeing two Ostermeier productions, I was pretty sure I knew what I was getting myself into— modern & re-interpreted text; live video projections; fourth wall shattered to pieces; nudity…

I’ve seen two of his shows—I know his shtick—

Whilst Hellman’s play takes place in the all-American south circa early 1900’s, Ostermeier’s production, takes place in modern day bourgeois Berlin. The fourth-wall is upheld with no video cameras in sight. The stage setting was smart and sleek—dark leather furniture, a grand piano and an ominous metal staircase. The upstage wall opens and reveals the brightly lit dining room. Everything onstage had a purpose and supported the action and conflict onstage.

Ostermeier’s an amazing director. He creates theatre that’s honest—to both the writer and the text. What’s at the heart of the play? He strives to illuminate the dark and desperate truth—a universal truth that needs no language.


So then what is Ostermeier’s trademark? The illumination of humanity? Can that even define his style? DO I need to categorize his work? I have so many questions…

Instead of sleeping...

...I write. Today was the oddest of days. This morning I had my usual fight with my body about functioning (I say I need to do things, my body says no), and then we walked from the S-bahn station to Topographie des Terrors, a documentation of Nazi war crimes. Or, as I think is perhaps a better way to phrase it, a documentation of the absolute horror and mess Germany was in the period after WWI through at least the construction and destruction of the Berlin Wall and the reunification of Germany. I have always had a strange relationship to my German heritage. I'm simultaneously proud and full of guilt, because I love being German, and because a friend of mine "forgave me" for the Holocaust (I won't touch that one too much, but even as an American whose German great-grandparents emigrated before the war, there's always been some implication of guilt).

I picked up a ring at a flea market which has "Vaterland's Dank 1914" on it. Whether or not it's from 1914 or not is debatable, but the rings were given to the women who gave up their jewelry during World War I to the war effort. They received this simple silver band in exchange, and it became incredibly fashionable to wear one as a sign of patriotism. This ring, among others, was on my finger walking into the Topographie des Terrors. Internally, I had a debate. Was it right to wear an emblem of German patriotism into a museum detailing the very worst of German "patriotism"? But I decided: if I was claiming my own German heritage, and not just kidding about some day wanting to live here, I should face exactly what contemporary German society faces, and not romanticize a German identity.

I read nearly every sign. Had I read every sign it would have taken me closer to three hours to get through the whole museum, and given everyone else had finished, I felt some obligation to hurry up at least a little. Before getting even a third of the way through, I was angry. Justice was absent here. A man who helped plan thousands of murders, known to have done so, gets seven years in prison. Another, ten. Another, perhaps a year as a prisoner of war. Declared "permanently unfit to stand trial." Some are executed, and I, one who can't stand even fictional violence, who was even discomfited by the celebration at Osama bin Laden's death because we as Americans were celebrating the end of a human life no matter how terrible, had a single thought: "good." Far worse was confronting the fact that not only did a large number of those culpable escape severe punishment or punishment all together, many actually held continued positions in government. Somehow more heinous than this was the fact that one high-ranking Nazi official went untried-- and finished out his days as a real estate agent. Nothing could be more absurd. The detailing of the murder of psychiatric patients, especially children, only served to further my disgust and anger. I claimed my American-ness more than I ever have before.

And this was followed by the beautiful and upsetting Holocaust memorial. Walking there, I was disgusted with the Berlin I loved before I walked into the museum. Once there, I wandered, almost feeling like I was in a meditation labyrinth. And then I crossed paths with one person after another, who were taking pictures and smiling, or running through the rows. I was pushed over the edge by parents with two children- on scooters. Rattle rattle rattle went the scooters over the cobblestone-like pavement. It was clearly a happy outing, and I wanted to say in my s--- German, "this isn't a playground!" I felt like these parents hadn't said anything to their (albeit young) children about what this place meant, or stood for, and to them it was merely a very cool place to ride their scooters. I ran into Kristen, we talked quietly, and I told her this story. Tears started to run down my cheeks, and I wasn't entirely sure why or whether they were justified or whether my anger was justified or where I belonged. I was hot, dehydrated, and disoriented. All I could do was walk back to the S-bahn station and wipe the tears from my cheeks.

I ate. Worked on a script for my summer camp job, mindlessly retyping a script so I can edit it. Wondered if it would somehow be inappropriate to go to the pool as I had planned, since today would likely be the last day I could. I met my classmates in the lobby, and no one wanted to come, which was expected, and fine. I went back to my room, debated, and then decided to go. 

Allegra walked in just as I was about to leave. We went together, and had a pretty darn good time. I went to dinner by myself, and sat outside, facing the street, watching. Absentmindedly I ran my fingers around the stem of my glass, and felt immensely at peace and grateful that I could sit and have dinner, and a drink, and a beautiful day at the pool with a friend.

At the museum, I was reading the backstory of all of the various men who were profiled. It said where they were born, and where they went to school, and what level they reached, their professions, how they joined the party, etc. Hitler was a failed artist, and there are those who claim that if somebody had just let him be a painter, he would never have become a politician and thus none of the atrocities would have happened. This, I think, is largely wishful thinking and apocryphal storytelling. But I looked for art and education in the lives of these men. Many had little more than a high school education, but others were doctors. One was the son of an opera singer. My theory about how art and education could have prevented these men from becoming what they did (and the women who also participated, because I won't exclude them) went out the window. As an artist, certainly I like to think art has a great deal of power. It's why an actor was one of the many brought in for questioning and imprisonment by the Gestapo--because he was an actor. Because political regimes suppress art and artists because artists like Ai Wei Wei among so many others make statements about things too big to ignore, things that the governments would prefer to push under the rug. But in the face of such utter collapse of humanity (in the traditional sense, since I also noted that only humans have the capability and do torture and systematically eliminate each other), how does art stand up? How does anything have meaning in the face of this?

I'm directing Anouilh's Antigone this summer with kids, and part of that process will entail talking about what it means, and the historical context of the play (Anouilh got it past Nazi censors in occupied France in 1943, despite the fact that it's fairly clearly a challenge to authoritarian governments...). And just today I was re-reading a conversation between Antigone and Creon in which Antigone acknowledges how pointless her actions are, and Creon asks her to be practical, since clearly she can't accomplish anything any way. One person can't independently overturn an entire culture. And yet Antigone tries, just as the small numbers of people in the various Resistance movements fought against those with power. And sometimes each action is just an act of preserving some sense of humanity. Art, to me, preserves our sense of humanity, even if it doesn't have the power to change anything. It is not unlike being aware of the glass under my fingers at the restaurant, and tasting the liquid and feeling being alive. Perhaps this makes no sense at all, but theater in particular is an expression of what it is to be alive, and like that moment at the restaurant outside, is fleeting and only serves to open one's eyes, and does little more than that.

But that can make all the difference.

INDIGNANT!

What an emotion roller coaster the past few days has been. Between the Ai Wei Wei's Evidence exhibit and the Topography of Terror, it is a wonder how people remain apathetic to the horrors this city (and the world) has experienced and are experiencing.

I am tired of seeing people take selfies on a gravesite. Smiling in front of gates at a fucking concentration camp. Perhaps it is the preciousness that our culture tends to endow specific events (and art) that we've talked about. And I understand the argument of moving forward from a shitty past (putting it mildly). However, there is a difference between respect and ignorance. 

It makes me wonder if the experimental and confrontational theater they have here is a result of the history in this city. The unresolved (abrupt) ending of Tartuffe had me hungover for the night. I find that the theater culture here has caused me to confront my thoughts about theater, religion, morals, madness and so much. 

Screwing with the Text

Tartuffe...
Tartuffe...

Where do I even begin?

It was definitely not like how I imagined it when I first read the play.

But then again, when the set is a moving box that revolves standing up and everybody is just flying everywhere, then you know you are not in for the typical, 17th-century depiction.

While the play had its comedic moments, this take on Tartuffe was not comedy. It was a lot darker in just...everything really. I'm still so hooked on the fact that Tartuffe was portrayed as this cult-like, not-Antichrist-but-some-form-of-alternative-Jesus-like-figure rockstar (he had the long hair, and at some point he was posed as if he were crucified)...which was something I could bet Moliere did not imagine Tartuffe to be such a character.

Michael Thalheimer also decided to include an alternative ending; he ends the play right when the bailiff comes in and evicts Orgon and his family. It is also implied in the end that Elmire leaves Orgon for Tartuffe.

We've seen a lot of performances here in Berlin--especially at Schaubuhne--that do not stick to the text one hundred percent. In Ostermeier's Hamlet, Ostermeier included a lot of modern-day profanity and fourth wall-breaking. He also moved the "To be" speech to the beginning, took out the first scene with the guards and the ghost of Hamlet's father, and replaced it with the king's funeral. In Death in Venice, half of the story was not even said--it was basically performed as an interpretive dance. Additionally, Ostermeier had the actors stop halfway through to reevaluate the direction of the performance. Now with Tartuffe, we see "screwing the play" in a whole new level--the characters look like they came out of a Tim Burton movie, psalms are inserted into the performance, and the ending had been completely changed.

As someone who has done playwriting more than anything else, I feel like I should be insulted. Someone put so much effort into creating a piece for you to use...and all of a sudden you decided to do a one-eighty and change things drastically. I wouldn't mind you, as the director, adding some lines or changing some things to illuminate the scenes and the emotion behind said scenes, but don't do anything besides that. Anything beyond that is not my work.

No, it is still your work. The text they used was your text after all. But let's be real--nobody is obligated to stick to the playwright's work word by word. If that were the case, our experiences would be exactly the same every time we go see different productions of the same play.

There's something beautiful about giving directors and other theater makers that freedom though. You learn something about the piece that you never thought of before; you see it in a completely different light.

<personal story>

My director for Cabaret Theatre's Original Play Festival changed a lot of what I had originally written in my play for the festival. There was a lot that had been cut out in terms of the text (but that was actually for time constraint purposes so...). Instead of having the set be a little girl's room, she had only five chairs onstage. Instead of having my main character shout in anger in the last monologue, she made her cry and had the other actresses go and hug her. These were things that I never intended, but because I gave my director the freedom to do as she thought fit, I experienced my own work in a new light and gained something from it. I remember listening to the conversations my director would have with the actresses (each actress represented my main character at a different point in her life), and just hearing about what they thought about the character...they each brought something to my attention that I would have never thought of before.

I felt a certain way that I had never felt even when I was writing the show.

</personal story>

You can't get that sort of enlightening experience if you have a stick up your butt about text--whether it means adding more to the text, adjusting certain scenes, changing the set/setting contrary to the play's original idea, etc.

And just as I learned something from my director's take of my piece, I got something from each of the shows we have seen at Schaubuhne because these directors were daring enough to change things around. I saw the characters that I have been familiar with since high school in ways that I did not know were possible.

Sunday, June 8, 2014

Day 6 Spanish Midget Fly

It is absolutely incredible how ridiculous the shows are here.  And there is no exaggeration in my tone whatsoever.

The German sense of play was obvious in the show tonight.  The actors have a wonderful time catching moments with the audience.  When laughter is heard, the actor uses it.  This, all in all, creates an energy in the room that continues to move the show forward.  It is possible then to sit in a room for 2 hours and 45 minutes without dying!  (No sarcasm)

I sat in the theater tonight, and I had to rub my eyes from time to time to make sure what was actually happening on stage was real.  But I am still struck by the silliness and absurdity that is Spanish Midget Fly.

Day 7 Elektra

Today, I was reminded that bad theater exists...everywhere.

Day 8 Death in Venice

Schaubühne ceases to amaze me.

The Moment After

I am always curious by the moment after the show is done.

How does the audience feel?
What is the audience talking about?
How did everyone interpret the show?
What is everyone walking away with?
Did the audience like it? hate it? why?
What did the audience learn?
Etc...

I watched Tartuffe last night at Schaubühne Theater.

The lights bumped out.
Silence.
The lights turned on.
Applause.

After watching a disturbing, chilling, mind-blowing, thought-provoking, and emotional work of art, I didn't know what to do.
I sat in the chair and clapped because it was the "right" thing to do.

So I sit on my bed now and realize how abrupt German theater can be.
I say abrupt because no matter how powerful/hilarious/ridiculous any piece of work they transform becomes, the audience always has something to sit with at the end.
I have to wonder if this is because the audience here is fully engaged and open or because the shows are roughly 2+ hours long without an intermission.
Either way, theater here continues to surprise me.
Yesterday I fulfilled a lifelong dream! I toured the Flackturm at
Humboldthian Park. What had once been a  231x231 foot wide and 128 foot
tall concrete flack tower is now only a ruin (half of the building was
blown up by the French).  It is only partly visible because 80% of the
building is buried by rubble.  And yet it was one of the most impressive
structures I have ever seen. The building was (and still is) practically
bomb proof. Three towers in total were commissioned and designed by Hitler
himself in 1940 to protect Berlin from the increasing Allied air raids
during WWII. Each tower was built in only 6 months - all 550 million tons
of concrete and steel rebar of it. Back in 1942, when the tower I explored
finally was finished, the tower could put up a cloud of anti-aircraft
shrapnel constantly due to its ability to fire approximately 8000 rounds
of ammunition per minute.

Exploring the bunker was an incredible experience for me.  It took me back
to a world of chaos and war.  I couldn't help but be struck by the
incredible scale of it all. The enormous scale of what a group of people
were able to accomplish  in only six months was mind blowing. I couldn't
help having the hair on the back of my neck stand on end when seeing the
marked concrete walls where Russian T-39 tanks had blasted them and
knowing that real people fought and died in this incredibly massive
concrete box. As a WWII history enthusiast, I have always wanted to
explore a WWII bunker.  As a theater artist, I have also very much looked
forward to exploring Berlin and its many theaters.  I am struck by the
similarities I found in exploring the bunker and exploring Berlin and its
theaters. I am impressed at the scale of it all. I am amazed at the
ingenuity it took to build the bunker, the city and the many shows I have
seen. This City's theater is as solid as its bunkers and equally as
mysterious.